How is Spanbox different from Beeper? Does it use a bridge/server or run the real apps?

22
Looking at unified inboxes and I keep comparing Spanbox and Beeper. The big thing I can't tell: does Spanbox relay my messages through a server like Beeper's bridges, or does it run the actual apps?
MMaya Novak3mo ago1135 views

9 answers

18
Best answer
That's the core difference. Beeper routes your chats through bridges, your messages pass through their (Matrix) servers to be unified, which is clever but means a third party sits in the middle. Spanbox doesn't do that. It runs each app's real web session locally on your machine, the same login you'd use in a browser, and just puts them all in one window. Nothing is relayed through a Spanbox server, because they don't run one that can see your messages. So it's less 'magic bridge', more 'all your real apps in one tidy shell', which is the trade-off: Spanbox needs each app to have a web version, but nothing leaves your device.
SSean Osei3mo ago
This is the answer, thanks. – Cole Patterson 3mo ago
Second this. – Isla Fischer 3mo ago
19
Different approach. Beeper routes your chats through bridges and its own servers to merge them into one feed, powerful but your messages pass through a middle layer. Spanbox runs the real apps' own web versions locally on your machine, no bridge and no server in the middle, so it is more private, but each app stays its normal self rather than merged.
16
Different approach. Beeper routes your chats through bridges and its own servers to merge them into one feed, powerful but your messages pass through a middle layer. Spanbox runs the real apps' own web versions locally on your machine, no bridge and no server in the middle, so it is more private, but each app stays its normal self rather than merged.
BBruno Udoh2mo ago
15
Different approach. Beeper routes your chats through bridges and its own servers to merge them into one feed, powerful but your messages pass through a middle layer. Spanbox runs the real apps' own web versions locally on your machine, no bridge and no server in the middle, so it is more private, but each app stays its normal self rather than merged.
WWyatt Riley2mo ago
9
Beeper = bridge through their servers (great for iMessage-on-Android type tricks). Spanbox = the actual app sessions running locally, no middleman. If privacy/local-first matters most to you, that's the deciding line.
NNina Grant3mo ago
Second this. – Kai Walsh 3mo ago
This is the answer, thanks. – Katie Wells 3mo ago
9
Different approach. Beeper routes your chats through bridges and its own servers to merge them into one feed, powerful but your messages pass through a middle layer. Spanbox runs the real apps' own web versions locally on your machine, no bridge and no server in the middle, so it is more private, but each app stays its normal self rather than merged.
LLiam Quinn2mo ago
6
Different approach. Beeper routes your chats through bridges and its own servers to unify them, which is powerful but means your messages pass through a middle layer. Spanbox runs the real apps' own web versions locally on your machine, no bridge and no server in the middle, so it is more private, but each app stays its normal self rather than merging into one feed.
WWren Lund2mo ago
5
The flip side of Spanbox's approach: if an app has no web version (Signal, for now), Spanbox can't span it yet, whereas a bridge can sometimes. So it depends whether you value local-first or maximum app coverage.
LLiam Adler3mo ago
2
Been on both. Beeper's bridges occasionally lag or drop because there's a relay; Spanbox feels like using the real app because it IS the real web app, just docked in one window. Different philosophy.
DDana Boone3mo ago