What's the most secure messaging app that normal people will actually use?

23
I want to move my family onto something properly private, but it has to be something they will actually open. Signal is the obvious answer for security, but half my relatives will never install it. So I am trying to balance real end to end encryption against will-grandma-use-this. What do people recommend when both matter? And is WhatsApp being encrypted good enough, or is that a false sense of security given who owns it?
CChloe Warren3mo ago712 views

8 answers

22
Best answer
Signal is still the gold standard for security, full stop, and it is free and easy once installed. The install friction you mention is real though. Honest take on WhatsApp: the message contents are genuinely end to end encrypted using the Signal protocol, so the text of your chats is protected. The trade-off is metadata (who you talk to, when, how often) which Meta can see and does use. So it is not a false sense of security on the content, but it is not private in the fuller sense either. For a family where adoption matters most, WhatsApp with disappearing messages turned on is a reasonable floor, and Signal for the people who will install it. Telegram, worth flagging, is not end to end by default (only Secret Chats are), so do not treat regular Telegram as private.
EEthan Udoh3mo ago
19
Signal, hands down, end to end encrypted by default, nonprofit-run, free, and normal-looking enough that non-techy people manage it fine. Everyone you talk to has to install it too, that is the only friction. WhatsApp is the fallback if your circle is already on it, same encryption, more metadata collected.
SSam Bauer2mo ago
18
Signal, hands down, end to end encrypted by default, nonprofit-run, free, and normal-looking enough that non-techy people manage it fine. Everyone you talk to has to install it too, that is the only friction. WhatsApp is the fallback if your circle is already on it, same encryption, more metadata collected.
NNoah Solis2mo ago
16
Signal is the easy answer, end to end encrypted by default, run by a nonprofit, free, and it looks like any normal chat app so nobody struggles. The only catch is your contacts have to install it too. WhatsApp uses the same encryption if you need everyone to already be on it, it just collects more metadata under Meta.
AAmir Meyer2mo ago
9
Signal. Everything else is a compromise. The install is one screen, most people manage it if you send them the link directly.
BBen Kowal3mo ago
Been looking for this for months. – Isla Marsh 3mo ago
Solid writeup, cheers. – Sara Novak 3mo ago
9
Signal is the easy answer, end to end encrypted by default, run by a nonprofit, free, and it looks like any normal chat app so nobody struggles. The catch is your contacts have to install it too. WhatsApp uses the same encryption if you need everyone already on it, it just collects more metadata under Meta.
JJacob Wells2mo ago
7
Do not sleep on the metadata point above. Encrypted content with a fully visible social graph is a very different privacy promise than people assume. If that matters to you, Signal collects almost none of it, which is the real reason to prefer it.
SSana Bauer3mo ago
Signal install really is one screen, send the link directly and people manage it. – Omar Holt 3mo ago
Exactly my problem, following. – Sofia Walsh 3mo ago
Exactly my problem, following. – Rhea Diaz 3mo ago
2
Signal is the easy answer, end to end encrypted by default, run by a nonprofit, free, and it looks like any normal chat app so nobody struggles. The only catch is your contacts have to install it too. WhatsApp uses the same encryption if you need everyone to already be on it, it just collects more metadata under Meta.
MMarcus Reyes2mo ago