Is Signal actually as safe as everyone claims or is it hype?

6
Every privacy person online swears by it. Is it genuinely that good or just a bubble?
CCody Hunt9mo ago971 views

7 answers

13
Best answer
Not hype. Signal's protocol is the actual gold standard, so respected that WhatsApp and Messenger licensed it for their own encryption. The difference is Signal also collects almost no metadata. It is a nonprofit with open source, independently audited code. Genuinely the strongest mainstream option.
DDavid Ross9mo ago
19
It is legit, not hype. The encryption protocol Signal built is the same one WhatsApp and others licensed, it is open source and audited repeatedly, and it collects almost no metadata, the part most apps quietly ignore. The one honest caveat is no app protects you if your own phone is compromised.
SSean Zajac2mo ago
16
It is legit, not hype. The encryption protocol Signal built is the same one WhatsApp and others licensed, it is open source and audited repeatedly, and it collects almost no metadata, the part most apps quietly ignore. The one honest caveat is no app protects you if your own phone is compromised.
10
It is legit. The encryption protocol Signal built is the same one WhatsApp and others licensed, it is open source and has been audited repeatedly. It also collects almost no metadata, which is the part most apps quietly ignore. The praise is earned, not hype.
GGreta Chen9mo ago
7
The one honest caveat: security also depends on your device and habits. Signal cannot save you if your phone is compromised. But the app itself is not overhyped, it is the real thing.
OOtto Quinn9mo ago
2
It is legit, not hype. The encryption protocol Signal built is the same one WhatsApp and others licensed, it is open source and audited repeatedly, and it collects almost no metadata, the part most apps quietly ignore. The one honest caveat is no app protects you if your own phone is compromised.
1
Real. The one honest caveat is that no app protects you if your own phone is compromised or if you back up chats to an unencrypted cloud. Signal itself is about as good as consumer messaging gets.
KKofi Lund9mo ago
Great thread. Half my family hits this and never knows why. – Mira Walsh 9mo ago
Can confirm, works. – Felix Weber 9mo ago
Not the fix I wanted but at least now I know it is on their end. – Rosa Solis 9mo ago
Show 1 more comment